Bioshock
I bought this back in, like, 2015, and have made various half-hearted attempts to play it to no avail, because I found it too scary. My last attempt was pre-Destiny, i.e. before I became a tryhard fps gamer.
I’ve picked it again and play it on stream with friends, whose company is essential to me not freaking out from the creepy atmosphere. Apparently, Bioshock isn’t considered a horror game, but it’s spooky!!!
I’m terrible at managing weapons and combat, so everything is still very hard, despite playing on easy mode. The atmosphere and world-building are very cool though.